Pumpkin Pie Through the Ages
It
wouldn’t feel like Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie, would it? That creamy orange filling, the cinnamon and cloves in the air, the dollop of whipped cream melting into the warm spice. It’s a dessert that feels like comfort and nostalgia wrapped in a flaky crust. But pumpkin pie hasn’t always looked, or tasted, like it does today.
Back in the 1600s, early settlers didn’t have ovens or pie pans, and flour was often scarce. So, they did what resourceful people always do: they improvised. Instead of making pies, they turned whole pumpkins into edible baking vessels.
They’d scoop out the seeds, pour in a mixture of milk, honey, and spices, then bake the filled pumpkins right in hot ashes or over an open hearth. The result was something like a soft, custardy pudding, scooped straight from the shell with a wooden spoon. Simple, rustic, and sweet, it was the ancestor of the pumpkin pie we know and love.
As time went on, ovens became common, ingredients more available, and home cooks got creative. By the 1800s, pumpkin pie recipes began appearing in cookbooks, calling for flaky pastry crusts and the warm spice blends we still use today, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and clove.
Each generation added its own touch. Some preferred molasses for a deeper flavor, others sweetened theirs with maple syrup or brown sugar. Even the consistency varied. Some liked it silky smooth, others preferred it firm enough to stand on its own.
That’s the beauty of tradition, it evolves while still holding onto its roots. Just like families, recipes change over time, shaped by the people who love them. This year, consider trying one small twist in your own celebration.
Maybe add a drizzle of maple syrup or sprinkle candied pecans on top for a bit of crunch. Try baking your pie in individual ramekins for a charming single-serve option. Or swap the pie altogether for pumpkin bread pudding, pumpkin mousse, or even a crustless custard baked in a small oval Au Gratin pan. Whatever you choose, make it yours. The spirit of the original settlers’ dessert wasn’t about perfection. It was about gratitude, creativity, and making do with what they had. And in that way, pumpkin pie, however you serve it, is still the
perfect symbol of Thanksgiving.
Enjoying my newsletter? Please REPLY and let me know! Also, please forward this newsletter to 5 of your family members and/or friends and share the love!
Here's what just one GON reader had to say...
"Your newsletter always feels inclusive. No matter your age or family setup, there’s something that connects and inspires."
— Carmen P., Galena, IL
